YEE Meh
Jun 25, 2022
EB2 NIW 140 RFE experiences
I received my #EB2-NIW #I140 #RFE from NSC on Apr. 27th after almost 400 days of waiting. My RFE is asking requesting evidences from recommendation letter to job offer and challenged all my prongs.
Now I am about to submit the response very soon. I'd like to know if anyone who has filed I140 RFE before can share their story and timeline. Thanks!
ADVERTISEMENT
L DJun 25, 2022
I suggest you hire a lawyer
dak zekeJun 25, 2022
consult attorney
AnotherGrace GivenJun 25, 2022
Waoh. this is ridiculous; challenging all prongs!? An attorney should help you put in a good response to the RFE. Best wishes from a fellow EB2 NIW filer.
R BJun 25, 2022
Did you file your petition with a lawyer or by your self?
YEE MehJun 25, 2022
I am filing RFE with lawyer. I want to hear story from fellow RFE filer to know what might come next. My lawyer didn't share these experience with me.
Tobi AduJun 25, 2022
I agree that you should hire an attorney. I had rfe for all three prongs also and my attorney guided me on what documents to submit.
my case was approved less than 60 days later.
Don’t rush to submit! once you’re done with finding evidence, your lawyer would draft a letter to summarize and support your documents and then you can submit.
YEE MehJun 25, 2022
@Tobi Adu Thanks for your sharing. The thing I am not really sure is whether officers will take the evidence or they just dismiss you for no reason. It's good to see still some of them are willing to take a look
jj bbJun 26, 2022
did you not file recommendation letters with your application originally?
Tobi AduJun 28, 2022
@Yee Meh, one important thing my lawyer told me is that you’re response is all about volume, he told me that evidences are usually weighed before being read. They only have limited time to go through your evidence so they won’t be reading all of it trust me. The supporting letter from your lawyer is usually on top of the evidence and it ties all your evidences together, that’s the most important one.
YEE MehJun 28, 2022
@Tobi Adu, that makes sense. I did spend sometime with my lawyer to shape the response to address all the comments in RFE trying to fulfill what the officer wants. My lawyer really loves template style response and I spend some time to argue with them on the flow and logic. Now it's submitted and I am hoping all the best
IsaCat 🐱Jun 30, 2022
Hi YEE, Any update? how much did the rfe cost?
D GJul 14, 2022
does it mean that if you use a lawyer to reply on rfe chances are you will have your rfe approved? regardless of the content of the RFE? your insights pls,
L DJul 14, 2022
@JV yes they deal with RFEs everyday and know how to answer them strategically
YEE MehJul 15, 2022
RFE response received by USCIS July 7th, approved July 15th. I am glad it worked.
jj bbJul 15, 2022
Congratulations
AnotherGrace GivenJul 15, 2022
wow.....congratulations, Yee Meh. Finally, a breath of fresh air
D GJul 15, 2022
has anyone submitted a Business Plan in their RFE response? is it really required? thank you.
AnotherGrace GivenAug 25, 2022
@YEE Meh, basically got your type of RFIE, challenging all prongs. Received mail today. Did you basically have to resubmit all initial evidence and documents and add more? or you just explained out more what you initially sent. How many pages of response did you have sent back?
just trying to get a drift of a response type.
Thank you
